June 11, 2000
Reviving a Forgotten Miller Play
by DAVID MERMELSTEIN
OS ANGELES -- IN the film and
television empire of Southern California, with the largest talent
pool of actors in the world, legitimate theater is by definition
a supporting player. But between the extremes of the established
regional stages and tiny theatrical groups struggling to survive
are a number of surprising success stories. The Antaeus Company
is one of these.
Formed in 1991 as a research and study group for classically
trained actors who had strayed from the stage into film and television,
Antaeus (the name derives from the mythical wrestler) has 70
members, 60 of whom are actors. The roster includes familiar
faces, though many of the names are less well known. But regular
theatergoers will doubtless recognize Douglas Sills, Lillian
Garrett-Groag, Harry Groener and John Vickery, all of whom are
members.
Though the group has mounted only a handful of plays in the
last 10 years, its efforts have earned it a loyal following.
And it is this audience that has helped the company's latest
production, a revival of Arthur Miller's first commercially produced
play, "The Man Who Had All the Luck," to extend its
run twice. It is now scheduled to close on June 25. Critical
comment has been favorable, and a notice in Time magazine generated
the sort of buzz that most Los Angeles theaters only dream about.
M R. MILLER'S fablelike drama flopped when it opened on Broadway
in 1944. The playwright himself calls it "a strange play,
an abstraction." But the work has long struck Dan Fields,
a director and producer, as ripe for revival. Mr. Fields was
a young literary assistant at the Seattle Repertory Theater when
he happened upon Mr. Miller's play 10 years ago. "I hadn't
read anything like this from Miller before," Mr. Fields
recalled, "and its themes spoke to my own life questions:
does a man have control of his fate or not?"
Last year, on a visit to Los Angeles, he called an actor friend,
Paul Gutrecht, who had recently joined Antaeus. Mr. Fields knew
of the company and its reputation. While studying at U.C.L.A.
in 1995, he had seen a well-received Antaeus production of Chekhov's
"Wood Demon" at the Mark Taper Forum. Mr. Fields thought
Mr. Gutrecht would be ideal for the lead role in Mr. Miller's
play, that of a young man blessed beyond his, and everyone else's,
comprehension.
Essentially allegorical, "The Man Who Had All the Luck"
follows the progress of David Beeves as he makes his way through
a mostly ordinary Depression-era life. But the rough spots in
his path have an uncanny habit of disappearing. When his fiancée's
father blocks David's marriage, a "lucky" automobile
accident removes him from the scene. When the state decides to
build a highway, it runs right past David's gas station. As others
fail, he seemingly inexplicably prospers.
Mr. Miller, who has not seen the production, said by telephone
from his home in Connecticut that the play deals with a universal
concern: "Am I being watched or am I just a freewheeling
atom in the universe?" The theme, he added, was not properly
explored when the play had its debut. "They didn't know
what to do with it in 1944," Mr. Miller said. "Frankly,
neither did I. And the critics couldn't dig it. That's why it
was basically discarded."
The play, directed by Mr. Fields, is being presented at a
converted power station in the shadow of the old MGM lot in Culver
City. But Antaeus is establishing a permanent home in North Hollywood,
converting a warehouse into a 99-seat theater with a thrust stage.
Dakin Matthews, the managing director of Antaeus, bought the
property for $850,000 and is leasing it to the company. He said
the troupe might take up residence in what will be known as the
New Place Studio Theater by the fall of next year. The move marks
another addition to the NoHo Arts District, an area of commercial
redevelopment that has the support of the city's business and
arts communities.
Mr. Matthews gave credit to Mr. Gutrecht -- who did get the
title role in "The Man Who Had All the Luck" -- for
starting the process that has brought Antaeus its greatest success
thus far. "None of us had heard of the script," Mr.
Matthews said. "We felt it was an undiscovered classic.
And one of the things we like to do here is unearth buried treasure."
David Mermelstein reviews theater for the L.A. Weekly.